Connect with us

Politics

Court orders INEC to replace NDC candidate with primary winner

Published

on

A Federal High Court in Lagos has nullified the (INEC) Independent National Electoral Commission’s publication of Ibrahim Lukman as the Nigeria Democratic Congress candidate for Oshodi/Isolo Federal Constituency I in the 2027 general election, The PUNCH reports.

In a judgment delivered on October 20, Justice Akintayo Aluko ruled that Lukman did not participate in the party’s primary election and held that INEC acted in breach of the Electoral Act 2026 by publishing Lukman’s name despite monitoring the May 29 primary at which Olumuyiwa Owadara emerged winner.

The court subsequently ordered the commission to publish the name of the winner, Owadara.

The court set aside INEC’s August 1 publication of Lukman as the party’s candidate and ordered the commission to immediately publish Owadara’s name and particulars. It also awarded N1m in costs against INEC and Lukman.

The judgment turned on INEC’s own monitoring report, which the court said showed that Owadara “scored the highest number of lawful votes cast” at the primary.

The NDC also told the court that it conducted no other primary for the constituency and that Lukman did not participate in the exercise.

Despite this, INEC published Lukman’s name and particulars as the party’s candidate, leaving Owadara off the list.
Owadara told the court that he had completed his nomination forms and had them submitted to the commission.

INEC argued that it published the names uploaded to its platform by political parties, including the NDC. Justice Aluko rejected that explanation, saying it was not supported by credible evidence.

“I am of the view that the evidence of the 1st Defendant that the names it published are the names uploaded on its platform by political parties including the 2nd Defendant is not supported or corroborated by any credible evidence,” the judge held.

See also  Omisore obtains N50m Osun governorship form

The court further recorded that the NDC denied sending Lukman’s name to INEC and accused the commission of imposing him on the party, a power it said the electoral umpire did not possess under the law.

Justice Aluko held that because Lukman had not participated in the primary, INEC had no lawful basis to publish him as the party’s candidate.

“The commission has no lawful basis or justification to publish the name and particulars of the 3rd Defendant as the candidate of the 2nd Defendant for the said election,” the judge said.

He ruled that the publication amounted to “non-compliance with and brutal violation of” Sections 29(1), 32(1) and 84(1) of the Electoral Act 2026, which govern the submission of candidates emerging from valid primaries and the commission’s monitoring of party primaries.

The court also found no credible evidence that the NDC had invoked the statutory process for changing its candidate under Section 33 of the Act or conducted another primary.

“There is no credible evidence before the court to suggest that the 2nd Defendant as a political party took steps to change its candidate in line with the provision of section 33 of the Electoral Act or that another primary election was held by the 2nd Defendant,” Justice Aluko held.

He concluded that Owadara had established his case with credible evidence, adding that the primary was conducted in accordance with the party’s guidelines and constitution and the Electoral Act.

“It is my humble but firm conviction that the plaintiff has established by credible evidence that the primary election was conducted in consonance with the guidelines, constitution of the 2nd defendant and the Electoral Act and that the plaintiff emerged the winner,” he said.

The judge added that INEC’s publication of Lukman’s name “is in violent breach of the Guidelines, the Constitution of the 2nd Defendant and the relevant provisions of the Electoral Act.”

See also  I’ll never abuse Tinubu, he has my respect – Peter Obi

In reaching his decision, Justice Aluko relied on the Supreme Court’s ruling in Igboke v. Chukwu (2023), which set aside INEC’s publication of a candidate who had not won the relevant party primary.

Lukman had challenged the court’s jurisdiction, asking that the suit be struck out on the grounds that he was not properly served with the originating summons. He claimed he was in London when service was purportedly effected and denied that the WhatsApp number and email address used belonged to him.

The court dismissed the objection, noting that it had authorised substituted service on August 19 after the bailiff failed to serve Lukman personally. The bailiff’s affidavit stated that the processes were subsequently served through WhatsApp on August 24.

Justice Aluko found that the number used for service was the same one Lukman supplied to INEC in his Form EC9, an affidavit of personal particulars sworn to on June 27 and tendered by Owadara.

“There is, however, credible evidence before the court to demonstrate that the 3rd Defendant is not truthful after all,” the judge said.

The court also considered WhatsApp exchanges between the lawyers to Owadara and Lukman, which it said showed that court processes were exchanged on August 27, 28 and 31. Citing the Supreme Court’s decision in Saleh v. Abah, the judge held that service on a party’s counsel who did not deny receiving the processes was valid.

The judge further noted that Lukman filed no counter-affidavit or defence to the originating summons and had therefore “failed to controvert or deny the claims and case of the Plaintiff”.

Owadara’s legal team was led by Festus Ogun, Managing Partner of FOLEGAL, with Tofunmi Adetunji and Omobola Olayanju. Ogun said the judgment had affirmed the judiciary’s role in upholding the law.

See also  ‘I Am Under Attack’ – Kemi Badenoch Laments Racist Abuse, Hostility

“We are most relieved that the court has demonstrated once again that it remains an impartial institution of trust which dispenses justice without fear or favour,” he told The PUNCH on Tuesday evening.

He said the team had been confident in its legal argument against the publication of a candidate who did not participate in the recognised primary.

“The last-minute announcement of an individual who never participated in the recognised primary election as a candidate is a stain on the process and institutions manning the election and a grave injustice against the legitimate winner, which should not be allowed to stand,” Ogun said.

“We are happy the court agreed with us and ordered INEC to substitute the name for our client. This is a victory for democracy”

The NDC, through its counsel, Ikechukwu Onodi, argued that INEC lacked the power to substitute a validly nominated candidate, maintaining that substitution was an internal party matter subject to statutory conditions. He also argued that the commission’s role in primaries was limited to monitoring the exercise and seeking clarification where necessary.

INEC’s counsel, Segun Bello, argued that determining whom a political party sponsors was not the commission’s responsibility and that INEC was required to remain neutral.

On October 23, FOLEGAL wrote to the INEC National Chairman, enclosing a certified true copy of the judgment and requesting immediate compliance with the orders.

“We respectfully anticipate your earnest compliance with the said Orders of the Court,” the letter signed by Ogun stated.

Source: punchng.com

FOLLOW US ON:

FACEBOOK

WHATSAPP CHANNEL

TWITTER

PINTEREST

TIKTOK

YOUTUBE

LINKEDIN

INSTAGRAM

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Politics

ADC rejects claim it sponsored attack on Tinubu’s convoy 

Published

on

The African Democratic Congress (ADC) has denied involvement in the alleged stoning of President Bola Tinubu’s convoy in Abuja, accusing the All Progressives Congress of blaming the opposition for public anger over the economic situation.

The party’s National Publicity Secretary, Bolaji Abdullahi, on Wednesday, stated this in a statement while responding to allegations against the ADC.

“We deny any involvement in the APC’s current predicament. We also cannot take responsibility for citizens who are expressing their genuine grievances against a failed regime that has pauperised them more than any other in recent history,” Abdullahi said.

He challenged the ruling party to provide evidence to support its claims, saying, “They have no evidence to support their claims.”

Abdullahi also accused the APC of being responsible for political violence in the country, stating, “Every Nigerian knows that.”

He added that the ADC had earlier warned the ruling party about the consequences of its actions.

“We warned them a long time ago that they would have their day of reckoning with the people. Now, judgment day has arrived, and they are looking for someone to blame,” he said.

The ADC spokesman also questioned the APC’s account of the alleged attack on the President’s convoy, asking, “By the way, didn’t they deny that the President’s convoy was stoned at the mosque? Liars.”

The response follows allegations by the APC Presidential Campaign Council that the ADC and the Nigeria Democratic Congress were sponsoring protests and violence at political campaign events ahead of the 2027 general elections.

See also  Tinubu unveils grassroots movement, defends economic reforms

The APC campaign council, in a statement by its spokesperson, Dele Alake, on Tuesday, alleged that opposition parties were mobilising youths to disrupt its activities through sponsored protests, fake news and propaganda.

It also accused the parties of mobilising hoodlums to pelt Tinubu’s motorcade with stones at an Abuja mosque on November 13, shortly after the President observed Jumu’ah prayers in Garki.

The council said security operatives attached to the President’s convoy exercised restraint during the incident and that Tinubu directed the police to release those arrested over the disruption.

However, the ADC Presidential Campaign Council had challenged the APC to provide evidence linking the opposition party to the alleged attack, questioning the circumstances surrounding the reported arrests and release of suspects.

Source: punchng.com

FOLLOW US ON:

FACEBOOK

WHATSAPP CHANNEL

TWITTER

PINTEREST

TIKTOK

YOUTUBE

LINKEDIN

INSTAGRAM

Continue Reading

Politics

ADC files 17-ground appeal on Atiku’s candidacy, read full details

Published

on

The African Democratic Congress (ADC) has asked the Court of Appeal to restrain the Independent National Electoral Commission from altering its leadership records and the nomination particulars of its presidential and governorship candidates pending the determination of its appeal against the judgment of Justice Peter Lifu of the Federal High Court, Abuja.

The party said it had filed a 17-ground appeal challenging the November 5, 2026 judgment, which it described as fundamentally flawed, arguing that the trial court lacked jurisdiction to entertain the leadership dispute.

In a statement issued on Tuesday by the Director of Strategic Communication, ADC Campaign Council, Phrank Shaibu, the party said it was also challenging an earlier ruling that granted Bala Gombe leave to amend his originating summons despite an unresolved objection to the court’s jurisdiction.

The ADC maintained that allowing INEC to implement the November 5 judgment before the Court of Appeal determines the issues raised could undermine its appeal and expose its candidates to uncertainty.

It therefore urged the appellate court to preserve the party’s existing leadership and candidate records until the legal dispute was resolved.

Shaibu said the 17 grounds of appeal questioned the jurisdiction of the Federal High Court, Gombe’s standing to institute the action, the assessment of disputed evidence and the orders made against the party.

“The 17 grounds challenge the foundation, findings and orders of Justice Lifu’s judgment. The ADC has asked the Court of Appeal to examine whether the trial court had jurisdiction, whether the claimant had standing, whether disputed evidence was properly assessed, and whether the sweeping orders made against the party can stand in law,” he said.

See also  Appeal Court fallout: Makinde, Bala split over Wike peace deal

The party is also challenging the July 24, 2026 ruling in a separate appeal, arguing that the trial court granted Gombe permission to amend his originating summons while deferring its decision on the ADC’s preliminary objection to jurisdiction.

According to the statement, the party contends that the proposed amendment altered the description of parties and the capacity in which a defendant was sued without prior leave of court.

The appellant’s brief challenging that ruling was settled by Chief J.S. Okutepa (SAN), who leads the ADC’s legal team in the appeal.

The party is asking the Court of Appeal to set aside the amendment order and determine the outstanding objection to the trial court’s jurisdiction.

The ADC further argued that Justice Lifu proceeded to deliver judgment on a court process whose validity was already being challenged before the appellate court.

It expressed concern that INEC could act on the judgment before the appeal is determined, potentially creating a situation that would be difficult to reverse even if the appellate court eventually rules in its favour.

“INEC must not make changes that could preempt the court’s decision or put the party’s candidates in jeopardy while our applications are pending. We are asking the court to protect the subject of the appeal so that its eventual decision has practical effect,” Shaibu added.

The party said its decision to make the legal challenge public was intended to clarify the issues before the appellate court and assure its members and supporters that it would pursue the matter through lawful judicial processes.

See also  Ex-Kano governor Ibrahim Shekarau rejoins APC

The dispute centres on the leadership of the ADC and the legal validity of the processes through which its leadership records and related party affairs are being contested.

Justice Lifu’s November 5 judgment in the suit instituted by Gombe has thrown the party’s leadership structure and its preparations for the 2027 general elections into fresh legal uncertainty.

The latest appeal comes amid continuing litigation over the ADC’s leadership, with the party insisting that earlier court decisions recognising its leadership transition remain valid and have not been set aside.

The ADC said it would defend the rights of its members, its leadership and the decisions taken by the party, urging that no administrative action be taken on the basis of a contested judgment before the Court of Appeal has considered the issues raised.

The party’s applications and appeals are now before the appellate court for determination.

Source: punchng.com

FOLLOW US ON:

FACEBOOK

WHATSAPP CHANNEL

TWITTER

PINTEREST

TIKTOK

YOUTUBE

LINKEDIN

INSTAGRAM

Continue Reading

Politics

Jonathan fears post-election violence in 2027, read details

Published

on

Former President Goodluck Jonathan has expressed concern over growing political intolerance ahead of the 2027 general elections, noting that incendiary rhetoric could trigger a post-election crisis.

Jonathan, the founder and chairman of the Goodluck Jonathan Foundation, gave the warning on Tuesday at the 2027 Peace and Security Conference in Abuja, themed ‘Safeguarding Peace and Strengthening Social Cohesion in a Competitive Political Environment.’

Political attacks on candidates and supporters of major parties have intensified as Nigeria prepares for the 2027 general elections.

The convoy of President Bola Tinubu, the All Progressives Congress presidential candidate, came under attack on November 13, 2026, shortly after he observed Jumu’ah prayers in Garki, Abuja, with some individuals reportedly throwing stones and other objects at it.

On November 15, 2026, suspected thugs attacked the campaign convoy of Nigeria Democratic Congress vice-presidential candidate, Senator Rabiu Kwankwaso, and its Kano governorship candidate, Aminu Gwarzo, in Bichi Local Government Area, leaving several vehicles damaged and supporters injured.

Earlier in November, the convoy of Nigeria Democratic Congress presidential candidate, Peter Obi, was attacked in Calabar, Cross River State, while some of his supporters were reportedly assaulted at a Lagos town hall meeting last week.

Supporters of the African Democratic Congress presidential hopeful, Atiku Abubakar, have also reportedly faced attacks in Edo, Kaduna, and Cross River states.

Similarly, the African Action Congress presidential candidate, Omoyele Sowore, and his entourage were attacked on October 30, 2026, at a restaurant in Ado-Ekiti, Ekiti State. The Allied Peoples Movement and other parties have also reported attacks on their supporters.

The ex-President also raised concerns about conflicting judicial pronouncements, particularly decisions by courts of coordinate jurisdiction, warning they could undermine public confidence in the judiciary and push citizens toward self-help.

He stated, “As we gradually approach the 2027 general elections, certain developments in our political environment are becoming increasingly worrisome. As a former President, I receive calls from Nigerians and friends of our country across the world who express concern about the direction Nigeria is heading. Rather than the confidence and optimism we should be inspiring, there is growing apprehension about the likelihood of crises that may follow the elections. We must not ignore these concerns.

“Among the issues demanding urgent attention is the growing culture of political intolerance. There appears to be an increasing unwillingness among political actors to accommodate opposing views or recognise the legitimate right of others to compete for political power.’’

“This is compounded by political thuggery, the exploitation of our young people as instruments of violence, and acts of political brigandage. Equally disturbing are controversies surrounding some judicial pronouncements, particularly those involving courts of coordinate jurisdiction.

“While the judiciary has the constitutional responsibility to interpret the law and adjudicate disputes, conflicting decisions on similar matters can undermine public confidence in the institution and create unnecessary tension. We must protect the integrity and independence of our judiciary,” he further said.

Jonathan warned that declining public confidence in the judiciary could lead to citizens taking the law into their own hands, with potentially disastrous consequences for the country’s stability.

He also cautioned against the use of ethnic sentiments in the 2027 elections, warning that political rivalry could deepen divisions and threaten national unity.

The former President added, “These are precisely the concerns that inform this conference. We seek to hold a mirror before our political leaders and citizens, encourage reflection and promote a change in conduct that respects our laws, democratic values and shared responsibilities.

See also  INEC list rekindles APC’s post-primary crisis ahead of 2027 elections

“As I observed a few days ago in Lagos, if Nigeria must make meaningful progress, we must review our political recruitment process. Our present system remains vulnerable to ethnic, religious and other primordial considerations, which often prevent competent and credible individuals from emerging as leaders.

“As we approach the 2027 elections, Nigerians will be choosing leaders at both national and sub-national levels. We must therefore be deliberate about the quality of people we recruit into public office at both the state and federal levels. The future of our country depends on the choices we make. Leadership is very critical in the growth of any nation.

“Let us choose competence over prejudice, service over personal ambition, and national interest over narrow considerations. Our democracy must produce leaders capable of uniting our people and advancing our collective development.”

Earlier in his remarks, former Vice-President Namadi Sambo, who is the Chairman of the occasion,  urged the political leaders to view political differences as opportunities for constructive engagement rather than sources of division.

Sambo called for inclusive governance, responsible leadership and respect for the rule of law, stressing the need to build bridges across ethnic, religious and political differences to strengthen national cohesion.

“As a nation, we must continually remind ourselves that political differences should be viewed as opportunities for constructive engagement rather than sources of division. Our collective responsibility is to promote tolerance, inclusive governance, responsible political leadership and respect for the rule of law.

“Having had the privilege of serving our country at the highest level of government, I strongly believe that national cohesion must transcend political affiliation and personal interest. We must deliberately build bridges across our ethnic, religious and political differences and create an environment where every Nigerian feels valued, protected and represented.”

The former leader expressed optimism that the discussions and recommendations at the conference would strengthen public trust, democratic institutions and national unity, stressing that “Our democracy must be competitive, but our nation must remain united.”

In his goodwill message, the Minister of Defence, Gen Christopher Musa (retd.), cautioned political leaders against allowing political competition to fuel national disunity, violence and insecurity, urging them to prioritise peace and national unity.

The minister, represented by his Special Adviser on Strategic Communications, Mercy Bala, stated that, “Political competition is a fundamental feature of democracy. It provides citizens with the opportunity to make choices, express their opinions and hold those entrusted with public responsibilities accountable. However, political competition must never be allowed to become a source of national disunity or insecurity.

“We must understand that political parties and their candidates may have different ambitions, ideologies and programmes, but the peace and unity of Nigeria must remain a common priority for all. The language of political engagement matters. The conduct of political leaders matters. The responsibility of the media matters.

“Above all, the choices we make as citizens matter. We must discourage the use of inflammatory language, hate speech, misinformation and divisive narratives that exploit our ethnic, religious and political differences. Our political leaders must demonstrate restraint, maturity and statesmanship, particularly in moments of heightened political tension.

See also  ‘I Am Under Attack’ – Kemi Badenoch Laments Racist Abuse, Hostility

“Democracy should provide a platform for healthy competition and constructive disagreement, not an avenue for violence, intimidation or the breakdown of mutual respect. Ultimately, no political ambition is worth the loss of innocent lives, the destruction of property or the destabilisation of our country.”

The Chairman of the Independent National Electoral Commission, Prof. Joash Amupitan, cautioned political actors, sponsors and supporters against violence, intimidation and attacks on campaign convoys ahead of the 2027 elections, warning that those responsible would face prosecution.

Amupitan, represented by INEC National Commissioner, May Agbamuche-Mbu, said, “The Commission condemns in the strongest and most unequivocal terms the widespread incidents of political violence, intimidation, and attacks on campaign convoys and party supporters recorded across parts of the country in recent weeks. Democracy cannot flourish in an atmosphere of fear and bloodshed.

“Let me issue a clear and unambiguous warning to all political actors, sponsors, and their foot soldiers: the law will take its full course, and security agencies working alongside the commission will go after the promoters and perpetrators of violent campaigns without fear or favour.

“Equally, I must sound a stern warning against any form of harassment, intimidation, or physical attack directed at the leadership, staff, or ad hoc workers of INEC by supporters of any political party — whether within Nigeria or abroad. Election officials are public servants discharging a sacred constitutional duty; assaulting or threatening them is an assault on the Nigerian state and will be met with decisive legal consequences.

“Let me remind all political parties, candidates, and their supporters that the Electoral Act 2026 speaks with unmistakable clarity on campaign conduct. Sections 96 and 97 of the Act prohibit the use of abusive, intemperate, or slanderous language designed to provoke violent reactions, ban the deployment of private guards, thugs, or masquerades at political rallies, and criminalise any threat or use of force to intimidate voters or opponents.”

The INEC chairman noted that the Electoral Act 2026 increased penalties for electoral offences fivefold, prescribing fines of up to N5m or 12 months’ imprisonment for individuals and up to N10m for political parties.

He added that the law also empowers the commission to prosecute electoral offenders upon receiving investigation reports from the police.

The INEC chairman declared, “Peaceful campaigns are not a favour granted to the commission; they are a constitutional obligation owed to the Nigerian people. I urge party leaders present here today to hold their candidates and supporters, particularly the youth wings, to the highest standards of discipline, and to utilise the Inter-Party Advisory Council as a genuine platform for dialogue rather than a theatre of brinkmanship.”

In a related development, a former President of the ECOWAS Commission, Omar Touray, has identified public trust in democratic institutions and electoral processes as essential to sustaining stable democracies.

Touray added that public confidence in electoral and judicial institutions would help societies manage political disagreements and accept election outcomes, warning that a lack of trust could trigger political tension and instability even after credible elections.

Ahead of the Nigeria 2027 polls, he recommended that, “Political parties and candidates must exercise restraint and responsibility. Electoral complaints must be supported by evidence and pursued through established constitutional and legal mechanisms rather than through intimidation, incitement or extra-constitutional actions.

“The judiciary must be independent, accessible and capable of delivering timely and credible justice. Its decisions must command respect because they are grounded in law, impartiality and due process.

See also  Omisore obtains N50m Osun governorship form

“Security institutions must remain professional and politically neutral, protecting citizens and democratic processes without fear, favour or discrimination.

“The media, in turn, must uphold the highest standards of accuracy, impartiality and professional responsibility, recognising that the irresponsible dissemination of unverified information can deepen political divisions and undermine public confidence.”

The Executive Director, Goodluck Jonathan Foundation, Ann Iyonu, warned that insecurity, economic pressures and declining public trust could heighten political tensions ahead of the 2027 elections.

She cited an Afrobarometer survey showing that fewer than four in 10 Nigerians believe the 2027 polls will be free and fair, warning that electoral violence could threaten regional stability.

Iyonu noted, “As Nigeria approaches the 2027 general elections, our nation faces a complex and evolving political landscape. Political realignments, persistent insecurity, economic pressures, and declining public trust in institutions are converging to create a fragile environment in which political contestation, if not responsibly managed, could deepen divisions and heighten social tensions.

“The central issue before us today is not political competition itself. Indeed, healthy political competition is a defining feature of every vibrant democracy. The challenge lies in ensuring that competition is conducted responsibly, inclusively, and within the framework of democratic norms, and that political differences are managed in ways that strengthen rather than undermine national cohesion.

“At a time when West Africa is grappling with democratic pressures, violent extremism, unconstitutional changes of government, and growing public distrust in institutions, this conference could not be timelier.

“Across the region, governments, political actors, and citizens are confronted with the shared responsibility of ensuring that contests for political power contribute to national stability and democratic consolidation rather than fuel division, polarisation, and insecurity. Political competition must therefore be conducted in ways that strengthen, rather than weaken, social cohesion, peace, and regional security.”

She added that the survey found that many Nigerians fear vote buying, electoral violence, violation of electoral laws and manipulation of results during the 2027 elections.

Iyonu observed that most respondents still intend to vote, stressing that public confidence in the electoral process is vital to national unity, peace and democratic stability.

“Your Excellencies, distinguished guests, ladies and gentlemen, the implications extend far beyond Nigeria’s borders. As West Africa’s biggest democracy and economy, and a critical anchor of regional security, Nigeria’s ability to conduct peaceful, credible, and transparent elections is central to the stability of the sub-region.

“During its October 2026 pre-election fact-finding mission to Abuja, ECOWAS underscored that Nigeria’s management of the 2027 elections will serve as a barometer for the sub-region’s democratic and security trajectory. At a time when parts of West Africa continue to grapple with democratic backsliding, unconstitutional changes of government, a disputed or violence-marred election in Nigeria could have far-reaching consequences.

“It could further erode confidence in democratic governance across the sub-region, strain ongoing counterterrorism and border security efforts, trigger humanitarian pressures through population displacement, and disrupt trade and economic stability. For these reasons, safeguarding the integrity of our electoral process is not only a national priority but also a regional peace and security imperative.”

Source: punchng.com

FOLLOW US ON:

FACEBOOK

WHATSAPP CHANNEL

TWITTER

PINTEREST

TIKTOK

YOUTUBE

LINKEDIN

INSTAGRAM

Continue Reading

Trending