Connect with us

Crime

1,000 abducted Nigerians: Families beg as kidnappers go silent

Published

on

Many families of kidnap victims are living in despair as their relatives, predominantly women and children, continue to languish in various terrorist dens after being held hostage for several weeks or months.

From the forests of Kwara State to the insurgency-ravaged communities of Borno and the volatile hinterlands of Niger and Southern Kaduna, no fewer than 1,000 victims reportedly abducted in coordinated attacks in the first quarter of 2026 remain in captivity.

Findings by Saturday PUNCH showed that, unlike previous patterns where abductors quickly established contact to demand ransom, families now face an agonising silence; no calls, no negotiations, no proof of life.

Silence more painful than ransom

In Woro community, Kaiama Local Government Area of Kwara State, the abduction of 176 residents in early February remains one of the largest mass kidnappings recorded in recent times.

More than 50 days later, families say they have yet to hear from the abductors, although the victims, who were women and children, were paraded by their captors in a five minutes, 41 seconds viral video.

Speaking with Saturday PUNCH, Abubakar Umar, a relative of multiple victims, described the situation as a psychological torment.

“We are not sleeping. Every day, we wake up with fear. At least if they call, we will know they are alive. But now, nothing. No calls, no messages, nothing. It is as if they vanished,” he said, while his voice trembled as he spoke about the most vulnerable among the captives.

“There are pregnant women there. There are children. Even strong men cannot survive a long time in the bush without food, water or medicine. What about them? Sometimes, we fear the worst but we cannot even confirm it,” Umar further lamented.

Another resident, Ajike Ajiboye, who has two relatives among the abducted, told Saturday PUNCH that the lack of communication plunged them into emotional torture.

“We now pray for the kidnappers to call us. Imagine that. We are begging God that criminals should contact us. Because at least that will give us hope that our people are alive.

“This kind of waiting is worse than mourning. When someone dies, you cry and bury them. But here, you don’t know whether to cry or keep hoping,” she said.

The fear is particularly intense for vulnerable victims, including pregnant women, children, and the elderly.

A community leader, Shehu Abubakar, echoed the concern, saying chances of survival were diminishing with each passing day.

“If they are in the bush without food or medicine, survival becomes very difficult. These are the questions troubling us every day.

“Our hearts are heavy every day. We don’t know whether our people are alive or dead. This uncertainty is killing us slowly,” he said.

In contrast, the situation in Omugo community has followed a more familiar pattern, with abductors reportedly demanding N500m for the release of eight church members.

The President of the Omugo Development Union, Thompson Oladimeji, described the situation as devastating.

“Our hearts are heavy. Families are in anguish, the community is traumatised, and fear now defines our daily lives,” he said.

He urged the Federal and Kwara State governments, as well as security agencies, to intensify rescue operations and increase security presence across vulnerable areas.

“We need a clear and sustainable plan to prevent a recurrence of such incidents in Omugo and neighbouring communities,” he added.

Across both communities, frustration is mounting over what residents describe as the government’s slow and largely silent response.

We feel abandoned – Victims’ families

Families of the Woro victims say the absence of updates has left them feeling abandoned.

“The government is behaving as if it cannot see what we are going through; we feel abandoned,” Ajiboye lamented.

A coalition of 31 civil society organisations also raised the alarm over the prolonged captivity of the Woro victims, describing it as a serious failure of the state to protect its citizens.

“We want to specifically draw attention to the despicable circumstances under which 176 innocent citizens were held and paraded by their abductors. A situation where poorly fed and barely clothed children are exposed to harsh weather conditions is grossly condemnable,” the group said in a statement.

The coalition called for immediate rescue operations, prosecution of those responsible, and the establishment of permanent security presence in vulnerable communities.

The Kwara State Police Command said efforts were ongoing to secure the release of the victims and tackle kidnapping across the state.

300 missing in Borno

In Borno State, the story is similar, as more than 300 residents abducted from Ngoshe in Gwoza LGA during a March 4 attack by suspected terrorists remain unaccounted for.

See also  2027: How coalition can stop Tinubu – Osuntokun

While a few women have returned in trickles, most victims including children are still missing.

A resident, simply known as Yahaya, told Saturday PUNCH that families were living in uncertainty, adding that the few returnees among the kidnapped victims came back without their mobile phones.

“Some of the kidnapped women have returned. I’m not sure if they paid a ransom or not. However, one thing must be noted: they did not return with their mobile phones.

“We have seen them return one by one. Some returned to Pulka, some took refuge in Gwoza. I am aware that two of the women are currently in Gwoza.

“Some women came back empty-handed. No phones, no explanation, nothing. Others are still there. We don’t know who is alive, who is dead,” he said.

Another relative, who asked not to be named, said the lack of communication had pushed families into helplessness.

“We have no information. No calls, no contact. We only pray. That is all we can do now; pray and wait,” he said quietly.

The Special Adviser on Security Affairs to the Borno State Governor, General Abdullahi Ishaq (rtd), confirmed that there was no contact with the terrorist group yet.

When asked about the official figure of the abducted persons, he said he could not comment because he had less information relating to the incident.

When contacted, the Borno State Police Command’s spokesman, Nahum Daso, told one of our correspondents that he had no update on the number of people still held in captivity.

Captivity stretching to a year

In Niger State, the crisis has taken an even more prolonged dimension.

There have been many terrorists’ attacks and abductions particularly in Mariga, Munya and Shiroro LGAs in which the fate of captives is in the balance.

The latest incident occurred on Easter Sunday in three communities in Shiroro LGA.

Sources put the figure of abducted persons at over 40, including women and children.

A worker at the council, who gave his name as Mustapha, said the bandits singled out communities in Shiroro for the operation.

“They stormed the LGA before Easter; they came again during Easter and they have returned twice. Since then, they have abducted more than 40 people. It is either the security agents do not exist or they have surrendered to the terrorists’ superior firepower.

“Residents are all fleeing to neighbouring communities. They took away my neighbour’s two children and have not made any contact with the family,” Mustapha said.

Saturday PUNCH gathered that some families that managed to make part payment for the release of their loved ones were still denied their freedom, as the terrorists insisted on full payment.

It was further learnt that some of these captives had spent over one year in the kidnappers’ dens and had lost sense of time as their relatives and loved ones had ceased making efforts to help them regain their freedom.

Our correspondent learnt that some of the captives died and were buried in unmarked graves without their relatives knowing about their deaths.

A former Chairman of the Niger State Universal Basic Education, Mohammed Niworu, and the Niger State INEC Commissioner, Ahmed, were abducted in September 2025.

They were abducted in Borgu LGA along with 30 others while travelling in three separate vehicles.

A family member of the SUBEB chairman, Sofiyat, said the government abandoned them in their most trying times.

“I am short of words. I can’t believe that my brother is in the hands of the terrorists.  We don’t even know whether he is still alive or dead.

“If he is dead, at least we deserve to see his corpse, but if he is still alive, the government should come to our aid and ensure his freedom. I can’t even imagine that it has been 10 months since he was abducted,” she said.

“Since that kidnap, we have not stopped praying to Allah to free him. We have also made several efforts to get the state government to intervene. Everything has been futile.

“The kidnappers were initially contacting us but they stopped after they received some money from us. They want us to pay the ransom in full. Where can we get such money?

“The whole thing is weighing me down. The federal and state governments must get involved if they actually value the lives of their employees. Joy and laughter have since left our family. We are now a shadow of ourselves, God please intervene,” Sofiyat cried

See also  JUST IN: Striking nurses suspend industrial action – Health Minister

A security analyst, Ahmed Sani, lamented the incident.

“For almost 10 months they have remained in captivity. The family of the SUBEB chairman managed to raise N40m for his freedom but the terrorists insisted that unless the full payment of over N100m was paid, they would not free him.

“The state and federal governments did not make any efforts for their freedom, being employees of the governments or so it seems. Ever since, they have remained in the captivity of the terrorists. Their families are not sure whether they are alive or dead,” he said.

A security source in the state put the figure of those in captivity in the state at over 250, most of them travellers.

The spokesman for the Niger State Police Command, Wasiu Abiodun, confirmed the attacks across the state, but did not confirm the number of abducted persons.

He, however, disclosed that security operatives were on the trail of the terrorists.

S’Kaduna: Families left without direction

Across several affected communities in Southern Kaduna, families say the silence of abductors marks a troubling shift from previous patterns, where kidnappers typically made contact within days to demand ransom.

Findings by Saturday PUNCH indicate that in the first quarter of 2026 alone, hundreds of residents, mostly women and children, were abducted in coordinated attacks on rural settlements.

Many remain unaccounted for amid what observers describe as a growing trend of “silent captivity.”

A resident of Ungwan Tama in Kachia LGA of Kaduna State, Daniel Samaila, told one of our correspondents that nine persons were kidnapped on January 20, 2026, including five members of his family.

He identified the victims as Patricia Zacharia, Evelyn Zacharia, Ruth Zacharia, Patience Istifanus, Jessica Istifanus, Gloria Joel, Blessing Daniel, and Jovita Joel.

According to him, the experience of having loved ones held in captivity under harsh conditions is devastating.

“The bandits are demanding N10m as ransom. We cannot raise that kind of money, even though we have been communicating with them.

“Sometimes, when they allow us to speak with them, they control what they say. They make it look like we abandoned them. It is painful because we are doing everything we can,” he said.

Samaila also recounted previous attacks on his family, noting that violence had become a recurring ordeal.

“Two years ago, a man was attacked in our community. Later, his family members were kidnapped on the farm, and his younger brother was killed,” he said.

A father whose wife and two children were abducted said, “Before, they would call in two or three days. Now, they do nothing. Not even a single call. We don’t know if they are eating, if they are sick, if they are alive. If they ask for money, we will sell everything. But now, what do we do? Who do we talk to?”

Another man, Jude Sadauki, whose three sisters were kidnapped alongside a cleric, said the financial burden had crippled his family.

“We have already sent money for a motorcycle. We are still struggling. But even that one, we don’t know if it will lead to their release,” he said.

In Kauru LGA, another victim’s relative, Jude Sadauki, from Karku community, said the abduction of his three younger sisters alongside a reverend father in February had left the family economically crippled.

According to him, the abductors demanded N8.5m and a brand-new motorcycle for his sisters’ release.

He said, “We have managed to send N2.3m for the motorcycle, but we are still struggling. We are deeply worried about their condition.”

Sadauki added that the ransom demanded for the cleric was far higher.

“For the reverend father, they are demanding N25m. It is completely beyond our reach,” he said.

Similarly, Mr Obadiah Dan Kaura from the Fadan Ruma community told Saturday PUNCH that his brother, Rev. Fr. Joel Nathaniel, who was abducted on February 7, was still in captivity.

“The terrorists initially demanded N50m and six brand-new motorcycles for his release.

“We have been pleading with them, but we can only raise about N8.5m. The family is already stretched beyond its limits.

“Since his abduction, our parents have been completely devastated. They hardly speak to anyone; they are always praying and crying over the condition of their son,” he said.

In communities where abductors have gone completely silent, the emotional toll is even more severe.

“We don’t even know if they are alive. Before, they would call and demand money. Now, they do no such thing. It is as if they vanished into thin air.

See also  Driver arrested over death of US-based Nigerian graduate, Oluwalayomi Fadero

“If they ask for ransom, we will find a way to sell what we have. But now, we are just waiting every day, not knowing what to do,” said a distraught Shuaibu Danladi, whose wife and two children were abducted during a night raid.

A security analyst, Musa Abdulwaheed, told Saturday PUNCH that when kidnappers refuse to communicate with victims’ families, it makes rescue operations difficult.

“It removes negotiation options. It makes rescue operations more difficult and riskier,” he said.

597 people kidnapped

Zamfara State has experienced a high volume of kidnappings, with hundreds of residents abducted in several mass incidents, particularly targeting rural communities.

Saturday PUNCH findings show that a total number of 597 people have so far been abducted in the state from January to April this year

On January 4, 2026, approximately 150 people were kidnapped during violent attacks in Tsafe town.

From January 15 to 18, there were attacks in Kaura Namoda and Tsafe LGAs, which resulted in massive displacement, with hundreds reported abducted or missing.

From January 28, at least 20-26 persons were abducted from Dausayi and other communities in Talata Mafara LGA.

By the end of January, reports indicated over 150 villagers were being held captive by bandits in forests.

On April 2, 2026, more than 150 people, mostly women and children, were abducted during a raid on Kurfa Danya and Kurfan Magaji villages in the Bukkuyum Local Government Area of the state.

Findings by Saturday PUNCH reveal that most of the abducted persons are still being held or even killed by the bandits despite the payment of ransom.

A father of one of the victims, Alhaji Samaila, said his daughter was abducted some weeks ago, but the bandits had yet to reach out to him.

“My daughter was abducted by the bandits three weeks ago and till now, they have not called me.”

An indigene of Damba area in Gusau town, Mohammed Ilyasu, said his elder brother, Sani Ilyasu, was abducted last week and the bandits called him once, adding that since then, he had not heard from them again.

He said, “When they abducted my elder brother, they allowed him to call me and told me that he was in a good condition. But since then, they did not call me again and I tried to call them but the phone number is not reachable.”

Speaking to Saturday PUNCH on the phone, the spokesperson for the Zamfara State Police Command, Yazid Abubakar, said the police command was aware of the incident.

Abubakar promised that frantic efforts were currently being made by the police command to dismantle the bandits’ camps in the state with a view to rescuing the kidnapped victims.

Children, families bear the deepest scars

Beyond those in captivity, the impact on families left behind is devastating.

Children are dropping out of school, and women have become sole providers. Entire households are collapsing under emotional and financial strain.

In many communities, relatives and neighbours now care for abandoned children.

A community leader in Kaduna State, Mallam Sulyman, said, “We now have children growing up without parents, not because they died, but because they are missing. That kind of trauma is deep.

“Even when they return, they are not the same. Some cannot talk. Some cannot sleep. The damage does not end with captivity,” he said.

We’ve converted victims to Islam – Terrorist

Meanwhile, in a viral video where a group of terrorists displayed 176 victims kidnapped in Woro, Kwara State, the hoodlums said they had converted their victims to Islam.

The voice in the video said in Hausa, “We are responsible for the abduction of the people in Woro and we converted them to Islam. We believe that they understand the religion. We taught them Islam and we are sure they now understand the religion. They now know the pillars of Islam.”

In the video, the terrorist asked the victims how many pillars of Islam there were, and they chorused, ‘five’.

Subsequently, one of the female victims spoke in Hausa.

She said, “This is the last opportunity we have to talk to our people. We have small children, pregnant women, and people with diabetes. We need urgent assistance. They are not beating us. They feed us properly. However, we need assistance.”

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Crime

NAF airstrike kills nine ISWAP fighters, commander in Borno

Published

on

The Nigerian Air Force has said its airstrike in the Sambisa Forest area of Borno State killed nine Islamic State West Africa Province fighters, including a key commander responsible for facilitating the movement and protection of senior members of the group.

The NAF said the operation was conducted on Saturday, August 8, 2026, following credible intelligence on the activities and movement of suspected terrorists within the forest.

The Director of Public Relations and Information, NAF Headquarters, Air Commodore Ehimen Ejodame, disclosed this in a statement issued on Sunday.

According to him, a Remotely Piloted Aircraft was deployed to conduct persistent Intelligence, Surveillance and Reconnaissance operations, leading to the identification and tracking of a group of terrorists moving towards a suspected hideout.

He said following positive identification and confirmation of the target, the aircraft carried out a precision strike on the location.

“The successful operation, conducted on Saturday, 8 August 2026, followed credible intelligence on the activities and movement of suspected terrorists within the Sambisa Forest area. Acting on the intelligence, the NAF deployed a Remotely Piloted Aircraft to conduct persistent Intelligence, Surveillance and Reconnaissance, enabling the identification and tracking of a group of terrorists as they moved towards a suspected hideout.

“Following positive identification and confirmation of the target, the NAF aircraft conducted a precision engagement on the location. Subsequent battle damage assessment indicated significant effects on the targeted compound, with several terrorists neutralised,” Ejodame said.

He added that further intelligence received after the strike confirmed that nine ISWAP fighters were killed, while several others were wounded.

See also  PHOTOS: Joint Lagos, Ogun security raid frees five abductees, leads to arrests of four kidnap suspects

Among those reportedly killed was Abu Khalid Al Muhajir, whom the NAF described as a prominent ISWAP commander responsible for providing special security escorts for the movement of senior members of the terrorist group.

The statement said his reported knowledge of routes, terrain and tactical movements linking major terrorist enclaves within the Sambisa Forest and surrounding areas made his death a significant operational setback for ISWAP.

The NAF further said intelligence indicated that some of the terrorists affected by the strike were linked to elements suspected to have participated in the recent ambush of Nigerian troops along the Bita-Yamtage axis in Gwoza Local Government Area of the state.

It said the latest operation demonstrated the effectiveness of intelligence-led air operations, particularly the integration of persistent surveillance with precision strike capabilities.

According to the NAF, the operation is expected to disrupt ISWAP’s leadership protection arrangements, movement of high-value personnel and coordination of activities across its enclaves.

The service said it would continue to conduct intelligence-driven and precision air operations in coordination with surface forces to degrade terrorist capabilities, restrict their freedom of movement and improve security for communities in the North-East.

Source: punchng.com

FOLLOW US ON:

FACEBOOK

TWITTER

PINTEREST

TIKTOK

YOUTUBE

LINKEDIN

INSTAGRAM

Continue Reading

Crime

Lagos man beaten to death over missing phone

Published

on

A young man identified simply as Azeez has been beaten to death by suspected cultists following a dispute over a missing phone at Oko-Oba in the Agege area of Lagos State.

A police source told PUNCH Metro on Sunday that the incident occurred on Monday, August 3.

According to the source, Azeez was involved in an argument with some of his colleagues over a missing phone after they attended a party.

The source said the argument later degenerated into an assault on Azeez by some of the suspected cultists, said to be his friends.

“We got a report that he passed away as a result of an assault on him by some suspected cultists said to be his friends. The argument was as a result of a missing phone,” the source said.

The source added that Azeez later succumbed to injuries sustained during the assault.

Meanwhile, an anti-cultism advocacy platform, Naija Confra, in a post on Saturday, gave further details of the incident, saying it began on Sunday night, August 2, during a birthday celebration.

According to the platform, a fight broke out at the event, during which one Abela allegedly took a phone and handed it to Azeez.

The platform said trouble started after the owner of the phone began searching for it.

It alleged that when the owner and his friends confronted Azeez after the phone was found in his possession, he told them that Abela had given him the phone to keep.

“Abela, who was sitting there, denied Azeez, even when people saw him. Azeez would never accuse Abela, an NBM leader who is also a boss to him, if it was not true,” the platform claimed.

See also  Tinubu swears in Doro, Udeh as ministers

Naija Confra further alleged that the owner of the phone and his friends, unable to confront Abela, attacked Azeez before leaving the party.

The platform added that Azeez later confronted Abela over his alleged denial of giving him the phone, leading to another argument and subsequent assault.

It alleged that Azeez was taken to another location by suspected members of the Neo-Black Movement, where the attack was carried out on him.

The state Police Public Relations Officer, Abimbola Adebisi, could not be reached for comments as calls made to her telephone lines were not responded to.

A text message sent to her had yet to be replied to as of the time this report was filed.

Source: punchng.com

FOLLOW US ON:

FACEBOOK

TWITTER

PINTEREST

TIKTOK

YOUTUBE

LINKEDIN

INSTAGRAM

Continue Reading

Crime

Speak out against terrorism, banditry, Tinubu urges clerics

Published

on

President Bola Tinubu has urged religious and spiritual leaders to consistently speak out against terrorism, kidnapping, banditry and the misuse of religion to justify violence.

Tinubu made the call on Sunday in Kano, in a goodwill message delivered on his behalf by the Secretary to the Government of the Federation, George Akume, at the Grand Maulud of Sheikh Ahmad Al-Tijani.

A statement by Akume’s media aide, Yomi Odunuga, said the President recognised the crucial role religious leaders could play in confronting violence, extremism and the misuse of faith to justify destructive acts.

He urged religious institutions and networks to strengthen advocacy for peace education, religious literacy, scholarship and the moral development of young people.

Tinubu said religious leaders should also use their influence to promote justice, responsibility, compassion and the peaceful resolution of grievances.

The statement read, “Your voices must be raised consistently against the murder of innocent people, against terrorism, kidnapping, banditry and the misuse of religion to justify cruelty.

“Your institutions and networks must become stronger in the advocacy for peace education, religious literacy, scholarship and the formation of upright young men and women.

“You must also remind political leaders of justice, responsibility and compassion, while reminding citizens that legitimate grievances must never become permission for lawlessness or violence.

“Above all, our spiritual fathers must continue to teach that no genuine service to Allah is advanced by destroying the innocent human life that Allah has made sacred.”

The President said the gathering was taking place at a time when societies around the world were facing conflicts, uncertainty, climate and food shocks, violent extremism, terrorism, transnational crimes and the manipulation of identity and religion.

See also  Ekiti Decides: Security forces mobilise as INEC moves sensitive materials today

Citing a United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees report, Tinubu said 117.8 million people were forcibly displaced worldwide at the end of 2025.

He said the scale of the challenges confronting the world has made spiritual leaders increasingly important.

According to him, spiritual leaders “guard the frontiers of conscience” through their ability to heal wounds, resolve grievances and address deep-seated hatred and bitterness.

Tinubu said the Tijjaniyya community, with its extensive spiritual networks across West Africa, North Africa and other parts of the world, could deploy its influence towards reconciliation, countering violent extremism, youth guidance and humanitarian support.

He said the Federal Government recognised the roles of religious and traditional leaders in promoting tolerance, countering misinformation and identity-based divisions, strengthening grassroots peacebuilding and fostering peaceful coexistence.

The President also reaffirmed Nigeria’s commitment to regional cooperation, counter-terrorism, maritime security, economic integration and dialogue.

He said Nigeria’s strategic position at the intersection of West Africa, the Sahel, the Lake Chad Basin, the Gulf of Guinea and the wider Atlantic world made the country’s peace and stability important to the region.

“Our position means that peace in Nigeria has consequences far beyond Nigeria. It also means that religious communities with deep transnational connections, such as the Tijjaniyya, can be valuable partners in building an architecture of social peace that complements the work of governments and regional institutions,” he said.

Tinubu said such partnerships should promote the ethical values of truthfulness, compassion, justice, restraint, service and respect for the sanctity of human life.

He also assured that his administration would continue to uphold freedom of worship while strengthening collaboration with religious and traditional institutions to promote peace, mutual respect and national cohesion.

See also  Real reasons Tinubu sacked ex-IG Egbetokun revealed

The President welcomed the World Khalifa of the Tijjaniyya Order, scholars, spiritual leaders and other guests who travelled from Algeria, Morocco, Senegal, Egypt and other countries for the Maulud.

He described Nigeria as a country where the Tijjaniyya tradition had established deep roots in scholarship, remembrance, service, moral instruction and peaceful community life.

Tinubu also paid tribute to the late Sheikh Dahiru Usman Bauchi, whose foundation played a significant role in organising the Maulud.

He described the late Islamic scholar, who died in November 2025, as “a teacher, a father and a voice of moderation and reason, and as an advocate of peace and piety.”

The President said preserving Sheikh Dahiru’s legacy of Qur’anic scholarship, moral instruction, devotion to Allah, respect for learning, peaceful coexistence and concern for society would be the most enduring tribute to him.

He commended the Supreme Council of the Tijjaniyya, the Sheikh Dahiru Usman Bauchi Foundation, the Kano State Government, scholars, traditional rulers, security and emergency services, organisers and volunteers for their contributions to the event.

Tinubu added, “Nigeria is honoured by your presence, and we pray that you return to your homes safely, carrying with you the affection and hospitality of the Nigerian people. May Almighty Allah accept the prayers and acts of devotion offered at this Maulud.”

The call came against the backdrop of renewed debate over the role of religious leaders in Nigeria’s political and governance affairs.

On July 28, the Catholic Bishops’ Conference of Nigeria, led by Archbishop Matthew Ndagoso, met with Tinubu and raised concerns over the country’s security and economic challenges.

See also  PHOTOS: FG announces arrest of Kuje prison break masterminds and top Al-Qaeda affiliate leaders

Speaking after the meeting, former Catholic Archbishop of Abuja, John Cardinal Onaiyekan, said some people around the President were presenting a “rosy picture” of the situation in the country.

He also warned that the government appeared determined to win future elections “by all means.”

The remarks triggered public debate over the role of religious leaders in governance and politics, with some members of the Presidency and the Federal Government accusing the cleric of partisanship.

Source: punchng.com

FOLLOW US ON:

FACEBOOK

TWITTER

PINTEREST

TIKTOK

YOUTUBE

LINKEDIN

INSTAGRAM

Continue Reading

Trending